Free Manager Checklist for Performance Appraisal

Conducting a performance appraisal requires meticulous planning and effective communication to ensure a fair and constructive evaluation.

Goal Review:

• Begin the appraisal by revisiting the goals set for the performance period.

• Assess the extent to which the employee met, exceeded, or fell short of these objectives.

• Encourage a two-way discussion to understand the employee's perspective on goal attainment.

Objective Data Gathering:

• Collect objective data to support the evaluation, including performance metrics, project outcomes, and achievements.

• Review attendance records, quality of work, and any other quantifiable measures relevant to the role.

• Consider feedback from peers, subordinates, and other stakeholders.

Strengths Recognition:

• Acknowledge and highlight the employee's strengths and positive contributions.

• Provide specific examples of commendable performance, emphasizing the impact on team or organizational success.

• Foster a positive atmosphere by recognizing achievements and reinforcing valued behaviors.

Areas for Improvement:

• Identify specific areas where improvement is needed, focusing on performance-related issues rather than personal traits.

• Offer constructive feedback with actionable suggestions for enhancement.

• Discuss potential training or development opportunities to support improvement efforts.

Developmental Goals:

• Collaborate with the employee to establish meaningful and achievable developmental goals.

• Align developmental goals with the employee's career aspirations and organizational needs.

• Discuss the resources and support available for achieving these goals.

Competency Assessment:

• Evaluate the employee's competencies based on the required skills for the role.

• Identify areas where competencies are demonstrated effectively and those that may require further development.

• Discuss strategies for enhancing competencies and skills.

Feedback Delivery:

• Deliver feedback in a constructive and professional manner, maintaining a focus on performance rather than personality.

• Use clear and specific language to convey both positive feedback and areas for improvement.

• Encourage open dialogue, allowing the employee to share their perspectives and insights.

Recognition of Extra Efforts:

• Acknowledge and appreciate any extra efforts or contributions that go beyond the standard expectations.

• Connect extra efforts to the overall success of the team or organization.

• Reinforce a culture of appreciation for dedication and initiative.

Goal Setting for the Future:

• Collaboratively set performance goals for the upcoming period, ensuring they are SMART (Specific, Measurable, Achievable, Relevant, and Time-bound).

• Align future goals with the organization's objectives and the employee's career development plan.

• Establish a plan for regular check-ins to monitor progress and provide ongoing feedback.

Developmental Support:

• Discuss the support available for the employee's professional development.

• Identify relevant training programs, mentorship opportunities, or resources that can aid in skill enhancement.

• Reinforce the organization's commitment to employee growth and career progression.

Performance Improvement Plan (if necessary):

• If significant performance issues exist, collaboratively develop a Performance Improvement Plan (PIP).

• Clearly outline expectations, timelines, and milestones for improvement.

• Offer support and resources to help the employee meet the outlined objectives.

Documentation and Record-Keeping:

• Maintain thorough documentation of the performance appraisal discussion.

• Record key points, agreements, and action items.

• Ensure all documentation complies with data protection and privacy regulations.

Checklist Templates @ Template.net