Critical thinking is a huge part of a person’s mental framework. It is being trained and nurtured while in school. Students write journals for them to exercise their thinking and writing skills. They are given a certain topic to analyze and their subjective response is drawn from it. One kind of journal that serves such purpose is the dialectical journal. You may also check out word journal templates.
A dialectical journal is a kind of journal that tests a person’s critical thinking. It is usually used in literature and other classes that require analysis. Taken from the word “dialectic”, it is a form of intellectual investigation. It is arriving at a truth using a question and an answer. He is made to understand a literary piece and write his own thoughts about it. There are no right or wrong answers when it comes to these kinds of journals. It is also used to record behaviors and observations. You may also see excel journal templates.
Dialectical Journal Entry
Summer Reading Dialectical Journal Entry
Sample Dialectical Journal
More On Dialectical Journals
Dialectical journals are written to make people think more critically out of a given passage. When a certain passage strikes some inner and suppressed feelings within you, the response you write ends up being more critical and emotional at the same time. Observations and reactions are also recorded in dialectical journals, as these are essential in critical thinking. Analytical reasoning is also developed through these kinds of journals. You may also check out prayer journal templates.
Students in middle school also get to use dialectical journals. It trains them to think critically and analytically. It is a useful tool in analyzing literary pieces and events in history. Subjects with a heavy emphasis on academic discipline use dialectical journals to train the analytical thinking of the students. You may also see travel journal templates.
Dialectical journals are used to arrive at a truth that both parties have never seen before. To do that, there has to be logical arguments within the conversation. In dialectical journals, you are not confined to the easy true or false, or pressured that your answer might be right or wrong. You are made to dig deeper on a passage that is relevant to your life. Dialectical journals are about dissecting a text and getting its message. You may also see recipe journal templates.
Dialectical journals are easy to use and convenient. Students and people who love reading books and doing journals can use this type of journal writing. You may also see journal website themes.
9th Grade Dialectical Journal
10th Grade Dialectical Journal
Dialectical Journal Template for Literature Circles
How To Make A Dialectical Journal
Dialectical journals are not expensive and don’t have a complicated format. In making a dialectical journal, just follow these steps:
1. Get a new notebook.
The pages should all be empty and clean. Neatness is important in dialectical journals as a whole. If you have some used notebooks with lots of loose leaves, tear out the ones with writings on it and leave out those that don’t have. You may also see vintage journal templates.
2. Divide your page into two columns.
The left side is the passage taken from a literary piece, while the right side is the thoughts about it. Use a pen and ruler in writing the borders of the columns. On the left side, write the passage and its source material. Label it with “Readings” or ‘Passages”, so it can be easily found by anyone who reads it. The right side is labeled with “Responses”. You may also seephotography journal templates.
3. Choose a passage from the book that piques your interest.
There are several factors for choosing a passage. First, it must be something that sparks your interest. You should feel some kind of emotional attachment to it. It must remind you of your own experience in life, or something that reflects just that. Another factor for choosing a passage is something that should be a significant turn in the plot. From there, a long response can be written about it. You may also see inspirational journal templates.
The passage is also chosen when it effectively uses literary devices that make the whole image more vivid to the imagination. Another is when a passage has a confusing setup and vocabulary. Some passages also illuminate the character and the setting of the story, and it’s a good candidate for a journal entry. Lastly, a passage which makes you see what you haven’t seen before is an excellent contender for analysis and written response.
4. Respond to the passage.
There are various ways of responding to a passage in dialectical journals. One thing that you should never forget in writing a response is it should be specific and detailed. You can start by giving your personal reaction to the passage and continuing on how it relates to your experiences in life. Write about how you feel about the passage. You can also discuss the character and his actions, motivations, and purpose in the story. It also includes your agreement and disagreement with the author. You may also see dance journal templates.
You can also write a more detailed response to the passage. Connecting the passage to another text such as songs and films is a must. It also involves analysis of the literary devices used in the passage and how it makes sense to the whole novel. Another way of responding to a passage is considering a perspective of a different character and seeing things differently. You may also see coffee journal templates.
Responding to the passage needs time and critical thinking. Write everything you can and make sure not to go overboard into irrelevance. You may also see writer journal templates.
5. Review your entry.
Go over your journal again and see if there are lapses. If you think there are still areas that need to be improved, do the necessary editing of your dialectical journal entry. This cuts down unnecessary sentences and makes your response more relevant and cohesive. You may also see education journal templates.
Dialectical Journal Format
Dialectical Journal Template
Dialectical Journal Student Sample
How Dialectical Journals Are Graded
In schools, dialectical journals are given as assignments and projects to students to test their critical thinking. Teachers take time in reading each journal. The guidelines for grading the dialectical journal are as follows:
1. Following general instructions.
Journals should be neat and legible. Students who follow the general instructions of dividing the journal into two. The journal should also be organized in order to have a good flow in reading. The pages should be numbered and the passage to be analyzed is properly cited. You may also see magazine journal blog templates.
2. Interpretation of the text.
Any text taken from a source material should be interpreted. Interpretation means writing about your understanding of the passage. In interpreting a text, you should include your personal thoughts about it. Citing the use of literary devices such as theme, conflict, imagery, and point of view are also essential in making your interpretation insightful. You can connect these literary devices to your personal experiences as well. You may also see reading journal templates.
3. The significance of the passages.
The passages to be included should be significant to you and to the reading assignment being given. Failure to find a significant passage might give you a failing grade. It is a must that the passage you choose is significant and relevant for you to write easily. You may also see food journal templates.
4. The cohesion of the sentences.
The sentences should be connected and related to each other. This ensures that anyone who reads your response won’t have difficulty reading it. Make sure you write and rewrite your response before submitting the final draft. There should be a smooth transition to every sentence. Avoid making the readers feel like they’re just reading random sentences stitched together for the sake of having an answer. Avoid writing vague reflections. Running around circles is pretty useless for journals like this. You may also see travel journal templates.
5. Thorough writing of the response.
As much as possible, be straightforward and state all your points. When you are given an assignment, make sure you cover each question and write an in-depth response to it. Put meaning in your discussions. Do not make it too long or too short. Just write what you want to write. You may also see vintage journal template.
The response in dialectical journals contains commentary on the passage itself. The commentary should be read and identified along with the response. You can also put in your commentary on the literary devices used by the author and the way he wrote the characters. Their hopes, motivations, and actions are good areas for a commentary response. You may also like journal writing templates.
In writing, plagiarism is a big no-no. Do not ever copy someone’s work or an existing published work word for word. There are instances that another person chose the same passage as you did. It does not matter as long as the responses are different in writing, structure, and style. You may also like free journal templates.
Dialectical journals improve critical thinking. It conditions your mind to write relevant responses that sum up your experiences, thoughts, and arguments about the passage. It is an exercise for a more logical thinking that is needed in some aspects of life. You may also like free bullet journal templates.